Just curious (even though posting it on LJ will skew any sort of "real" results. Though I am hoping to entice some tumblrites to answer also).
I'm thinking about this because I have noticed a lot of LJians migrating to tumblr and it makes me wonder if that's because it offers a more rewarding fandom experience than LJ. For me, it's LJ. I enjoy tumblr but I can (and did!) go days without visiting it, but I can't go a day without checking into LJ.
Is tumblr a more rewarding fandom experience than Live Journal?
I can't say, I'm only on LJ.
I can't say, I'm only on Tumblr.
You can't compare. They are different experiences.
It depends on what you are using them for.
They are equally rewarding.
I find neither very rewarding.
I have another fandom space I find more rewarding.
Ticky! I can't decide!
Sorry what? fandom is rewarding? I missed that memo.
Other. I'll explain in a comment
I consider "rewarding" to mean where you get the most pleasure. Perhaps your "go to" fandom place. The one that is most satisfying as a fandom hangout. The one you feel most at home or perhaps the place you feel you belong.